Contractual Risks in SMB Acquisitions

When acquiring a small or medium-sized business (SMB), hidden risks in contracts can lead to serious financial and operational challenges. These include undisclosed liabilities, problematic vendor agreements, and unfavorable terms in existing contracts. SMBs often face higher risks due to limited resources and weaker internal controls, making thorough due diligence essential. Key steps to minimize risks include:

• Identifying Hidden Liabilities: Investigate off-balance-sheet obligations, tax issues, or pending lawsuits.
• Reviewing Problem Contracts: Check for restrictive clauses, auto-renewals, or penalties in supplier and vendor agreements.
• Choosing the Right Deal Structure: Asset purchases limit liability exposure, while equity purchases transfer all liabilities.
• Using Financial Safeguards: Employ indemnities, escrows, and holdbacks to protect against unexpected issues.
• Leveraging Technology: AI tools can streamline contract reviews, detect risks, and improve compliance checks.

A strong legal and financial team, combined with systematic due diligence, is crucial to avoid costly surprises and ensure a smoother acquisition process.

Understanding M&A Legal Due Diligence & Fees When Acquiring An Online Business with Eric Hsu

Common Contractual Risks in SMB Acquisitions

Spotting contractual risks - like hidden liabilities and unfavorable terms - is a critical step for anyone looking to acquire a small or mid-sized business. These risks can lead to unexpected problems if not addressed during the due diligence process. Let’s break down two key areas where these risks often hide.

Hidden Liabilities

Hidden liabilities are obligations that don’t show up on financial statements but can seriously impact profitability and operations. Think of things like unreported debts, off-balance-sheet liabilities, or even pending lawsuits. Other potential pitfalls include unresolved tax issues, undisclosed employee obligations, or non-compliance with regulations.

To uncover these risks, a thorough due diligence process is essential. This means diving into bank loans, credit lines, accounts payable, tax records, and employee contracts. It may also involve conducting environmental audits to ensure there are no surprises waiting for you after the deal closes.

Problem Contracts

Existing contracts can sometimes include terms that become a headache post-acquisition. Supplier, vendor, or service agreements might have clauses like penalties, auto-renewals, or hefty termination fees. These provisions can limit operational flexibility or create unexpected costs, especially if they don’t transfer smoothly to the new owner.

Carefully reviewing all agreements is crucial to avoid being stuck with unfavorable terms. This step ensures you’re not blindsided by financial or legal obligations that could disrupt your plans.

How to Reduce Contractual Risks in SMB Acquisitions

Reducing contractual risks is crucial to protecting the value and stability of small and medium-sized business (SMB) acquisitions. Once you've identified potential risks, structuring the deal carefully can help limit your exposure. The way you structure the acquisition sets the stage for managing liabilities effectively.

Equity vs. Asset Purchase Structures

How you choose to structure the acquisition - either as an equity purchase or an asset purchase - plays a major role in how liabilities are handled. Each approach has distinct pros and cons when it comes to managing risk.

In an asset purchase, the buyer selects specific assets they want to acquire and decides which liabilities to assume. This allows the buyer to exclude unwanted liabilities while the seller retains ownership of the legal entity. Buyers often appreciate the control this structure provides, as well as the potential tax advantage of a step-up in the asset's tax basis. However, this process can become more complicated due to the need for retitling assets and obtaining various consents.

On the other hand, an equity purchase involves buying the entire legal entity, including all its assets and liabilities. This approach simplifies the transaction since there’s no need to revalue or retitle assets. However, it also means the buyer takes on all liabilities, including any that might not be immediately apparent, which increases risk exposure.

Aspect	Asset Purchase	Equity Purchase
Liability Exposure	Only selected liabilities assumed	All liabilities transferred
Tax Benefits	Step-up in asset basis	No step-up in basis
Complexity	More complex (retitling required)	Simpler transaction
Risk Control	High (select liabilities)	Lower (all liabilities included)
Seller Preference	Less preferred by sellers	More preferred by sellers

Buyers generally lean toward asset purchases to limit liability risks, while sellers often prefer equity sales for their simplicity and tax benefits. Regardless of the choice, consulting a corporate attorney is critical before negotiations begin.

Indemnities, Escrows, and Holdbacks

Beyond deal structure, financial safeguards like indemnities, escrows, and holdbacks can help manage risk.

• Indemnities shield the buyer from losses due to undisclosed liabilities, warranty breaches, or misrepresentations by the seller.
• Escrows involve setting aside part of the purchase price in a neutral third-party account, ensuring funds are available to cover potential claims.
• Holdbacks allow the buyer to keep a portion of the purchase price directly, offering more control over the funds.

Typically, holdbacks range from 5% to 15% of the total purchase price, with 10% or more being common. Escrow periods usually last between 12 and 18 months. When setting up these provisions, ensure the amount held is sufficient to cover potential claims and aligns with the survival period of warranties and representations. Clearly define the conditions for fund release, including milestones and a robust claims process.

Buyers often prefer holdbacks for direct control, while sellers favor escrows to ensure the buyer’s ability to pay. Tax considerations also play a role - decide whether the escrow account should earn interest and determine its tax ownership.

Keeping Separate Business Entities

Another effective way to manage risk is by keeping the acquired business as a separate legal entity. This strategy isolates historical liabilities from the rest of your operations. For this to work, the separation must be thorough. Each entity should have its own bank accounts, tax identification numbers, financial records, and operational procedures. Document any relationships between entities with clear written agreements.

This approach offers flexibility. It simplifies selling parts of the business, supports targeted investments, and enables market expansion while maintaining liability safeguards. However, if the acquired business has strong brand recognition, weigh the benefits of separation against any potential impact on brand value.

"The decision whether to combine business lines under a single company or maintain separate companies for each of them largely comes down to two factors: the similarity of the business lines, in terms of opportunity and risk, and the increased costs and risks associated with managing multiple companies."

• Trevor Brewer, Business Attorney

Given that 96% of LLCs in the U.S. are small businesses with fewer than 500 employees, this strategy is especially relevant for SMB acquisitions. Creating a new entity also lets you choose a corporate structure that aligns with your management and tax preferences. Plus, keeping financial records separate makes compliance and reporting much easier. By combining these structural strategies, you can significantly lower the risk profile of your SMB acquisition.

sbb-itb-97ecd51

Best Practices for Due Diligence and Legal Risk Management

When acquiring an SMB, thorough due diligence is your strongest safeguard against unexpected contractual pitfalls. A systematic approach is key, and many buyers rely on detailed checklists to ensure all critical areas are addressed. Using a well-structured checklist can help you stay organized and avoid overlooking essential details.

The single most important step? Engage a lawyer to review documents with you. Legal expertise is crucial for navigating complex contracts and identifying potential liabilities. Beyond legal reviews, consider speaking with key customers for added perspective. If you're entering an unfamiliar industry, take the time to educate yourself before moving forward.

Contract and Agreement Review

A careful examination of contracts is the cornerstone of effective due diligence. Start by requesting and evaluating all relevant contract-related documents from the target company. One of your first tasks should be verifying that corporate records clearly identify the company's owners - any ambiguity here can lead to serious legal complications.

When reviewing contracts, look for pending legal issues, warranty claims, or government inquiries. These could signal hidden risks that might not have been disclosed earlier. Pay close attention to active contracts to determine if they include clauses restricting assignment to new owners, as this could disrupt operations after the acquisition.

Work collaboratively with the seller to identify any contracts that may not transfer smoothly. Additionally, check whether any agreements involve "set aside" requirements, such as those tied to government contracts or minority-owned business certifications.

Ensure all contract dates are accurate and payment terms are clearly defined. Confirm that the legal names of all parties are correct to avoid confusion about responsibilities. Review obligations carefully to ensure they are straightforward and not open to misinterpretation. Conduct a full review with your team to align on key points. Document any concerns, share them with relevant parties, and request additional information where needed. After this, shift your focus to regulatory and compliance documentation.

Regulatory and Compliance Checks

Once contracts are reviewed, turn your attention to regulatory compliance. This area can significantly impact the success of an acquisition. Confirm that the target business holds all necessary licenses and complies with relevant regulations to avoid fines or operational disruptions.

Examine reports from investigations, audits, or government inquiries to identify any ongoing compliance issues that could lead to penalties. If the company operates in a regulated industry or works with government clients, scrutinize those contracts for potential risks, such as fraud or abuse.

For businesses involved in government contracts or other regulated sectors, ensure they have a process to screen out excluded parties. Compliance isn't just about meeting current requirements - it’s about maintaining systems that proactively address potential issues before they escalate.

Industry-Specific Considerations

Tailor your due diligence strategy to the specific risks of the industry you're entering. Different sectors come with unique challenges that require specialized attention.

For example, healthcare acquisitions can be particularly complex due to strict regulations and cybersecurity concerns. During due diligence, assess the target's technology and cybersecurity protocols. Cybersecurity is a significant concern in healthcare, with the average cost of a data breach exceeding $10 million. A notable case involved a ransomware attack on a Chicago-based hospital chain that, following mergers, affected millions of patients across more than 20 states.

Healthcare businesses must comply with regulations like HIPAA, which, if violated, can result in severe civil or criminal penalties. Review the company’s HIPAA policies, training programs, and Business Associate Agreements (BAAs). Given that healthcare spending accounted for 17.7% of the U.S. GDP in 2018 and is expected to rise to 19.7% by 2028, regulatory oversight in this sector is only increasing.

Technology manufacturers face their own set of risks, including cybersecurity threats, supply chain disruptions, and compliance with both industry and government standards. The average global cost of a data breach in 2023 was $4.45 million - up 15% over three years. To mitigate these risks, ensure compliance protocols and risk controls are integrated throughout the product lifecycle.

Manufacturing companies often deal with intricate supplier networks and varied regulatory requirements depending on product type and market location. Special attention should be given to environmental regulations, product liability concerns, and international trade rules if the company imports materials or exports goods.

Each industry comes with its own regulatory framework and risk profile. Adapt your due diligence process to address these specifics, and don't hesitate to involve experts familiar with the sector you're evaluating. Their insights can be invaluable in identifying risks and ensuring a smooth acquisition process.

How Technology Helps Manage Contractual Risks

Technology is reshaping how buyers identify and handle contractual risks, especially in small and medium-sized business (SMB) acquisitions. While traditional methods often relied on manually reviewing hundreds of documents, AI-powered tools now streamline this process, delivering faster and more precise results.

For example, studies reveal that processing a simple contract costs an average of $6,900. On the other hand, some platforms have achieved an impressive 80% reduction in contract processing time, and electronic signatures alone can slash send-to-sign time by 20%. These advancements translate into measurable cost savings and efficiency gains.

AI-driven tools go beyond speeding up the process - they actively enhance risk detection. These systems can scan documents to uncover hidden risks, extract critical data points, and compare clauses against standard templates to identify inconsistencies. By leveraging machine learning, they analyze historical data to spot patterns that might indicate compliance gaps or concealed liabilities. This is particularly useful in SMB acquisitions, where documentation might be less formal or incomplete, potentially masking significant risks.

How Kumo Simplifies Deal Sourcing

Kumo’s AI-powered platform brings risk evaluation to the forefront of the acquisition process, making it easier for buyers to identify potential issues early. By consolidating business listings from various marketplaces, brokerages, and proprietary sources, Kumo provides a comprehensive view of opportunities, helping buyers catch red flags before committing to costly due diligence.

Customizable filters allow buyers to screen deals based on specific risk criteria. For instance, users can narrow their search to industries with simpler regulatory landscapes or avoid businesses with operational characteristics linked to higher liability risks.

Kumo also delivers real-time insights that help buyers track changes in business listings. For example, a sudden drop in asking price or updates to operational details could indicate hidden liabilities or contractual problems requiring further scrutiny. The platform’s deal alerts ensure buyers stay informed about opportunities that align with their risk tolerance and acquisition goals, enabling them to compare multiple prospects and make informed decisions. Beyond sourcing deals, Kumo’s advanced analytics tools provide additional layers of risk management.

Using Data Insights for Risk Reduction

Modern data analytics offer powerful ways to evaluate and reduce contractual risks. AI tools can automatically verify compliance with regulations, minimizing the risk of penalties tied to non-compliance. These systems also monitor regulatory updates and notify teams of changes that could impact the target business - an essential feature for SMBs that may lack dedicated compliance resources.

Machine learning further enhances risk management by analyzing corporate policies and practices to identify deviations or potential compliance issues. In SMB acquisitions, this capability helps buyers determine whether a target company has adhered to its stated policies and contractual obligations.

Fraud detection is another critical function of data analytics. AI systems analyze transaction patterns to uncover anomalies that might signal fraud or misrepresentation. With cybercrime costing businesses $2.9 million every minute, these tools play a vital role in safeguarding acquisition investments. By combining speed, precision, and advanced risk detection, data analytics significantly bolster the due diligence process.

Managing Contractual Risks in SMB Acquisitions

Managing contractual risks in SMB acquisitions requires careful planning, thorough due diligence, and the strategic use of technology. The stakes are high - overlooking potential risks can lead to failed deals or unforeseen liabilities that could severely impact your investment. To avoid these pitfalls, it's essential to approach financial and legal risk management with a strong, structured plan.

The first step is building a team of seasoned experts. This team should include legal advisors, financial analysts, and industry specialists who can identify potential red flags before they escalate into costly issues. With their expertise, you can create a tailored due diligence plan that aligns with the target company’s industry, size, and specific risk factors. This ensures a comprehensive review, leaving no detail unchecked.

Financial risk management is equally critical. Start by pricing contracts realistically and keeping a close eye on cash flow. Regular audits can help catch discrepancies early, while progress billing can ease cash flow challenges during the transition period. Documenting everything clearly is another safeguard, reducing the risk of disputes after the acquisition.

Legal protections are just as important as financial safeguards. Work with a government contract attorney to review terms, ensure intellectual property rights are secure, and confirm subcontractor compliance. Any modifications to contracts should be meticulously documented, and clear communication with all parties involved is vital to prevent misunderstandings.

Technology plays a key role here, too. Digital tools can streamline and enhance your risk management efforts, making it easier to monitor compliance, track financials, and manage contracts effectively.

The best acquisitions are those that focus on proactive strategies. Anticipating potential issues and addressing them before they arise is far more effective than scrambling to react after the fact. Strong relationships with stakeholders also help, creating a network of support to navigate any unexpected challenges.

FAQs

What’s the difference between asset purchases and equity purchases when it comes to liability in SMB acquisitions?

In an asset purchase, the buyer picks and chooses which assets and liabilities to acquire. This selective approach helps minimize exposure to unexpected liabilities connected to the business. Essentially, the buyer avoids inheriting any debts or obligations they haven’t specifically agreed to take on.

On the other hand, an equity purchase involves buying the entire company - assets, liabilities, and all. By doing so, the buyer takes on full responsibility for any existing or hidden liabilities. Because of this, conducting thorough due diligence becomes absolutely critical to reduce potential risks.

How can AI tools assist in identifying and managing contractual risks during due diligence for SMB acquisitions?

AI tools are transforming the way small and medium-sized business (SMB) acquisitions handle contractual risks during due diligence. These tools can swiftly sift through extensive legal documents, pinpointing potential trouble spots like undisclosed debts, pending lawsuits, or unfavorable contract clauses. By automating this labor-intensive process, AI minimizes the chance of missing critical risks that could impact the deal.

On top of that, AI-powered platforms bring data analytics into the mix, uncovering patterns and anomalies that help buyers make smarter decisions. For instance, tools like Kumo simplify the process by gathering relevant data and delivering actionable insights. This allows buyers to focus on opportunities with the most promise while addressing potential risks. Using AI in due diligence not only saves time but also boosts accuracy and confidence in decision-making.

What are the best ways to use indemnities, escrows, and holdbacks to minimize unexpected liabilities in SMB acquisitions?

When acquiring a small or medium-sized business (SMB), safeguarding against unexpected liabilities is crucial. One effective approach is to include indemnity clauses in the agreement. These clauses clearly outline how risks will be divided between the buyer and seller, ensuring both parties understand their responsibilities.

Another common strategy is setting up escrow accounts or holdbacks, typically amounting to around 10% of the purchase price. These funds act as a financial safety net, reserved to address any unforeseen liabilities that might surface after the deal is finalized. To avoid disputes, it’s essential to define the conditions for releasing these funds upfront. They should only be distributed once specific risks or obligations have been fully resolved.

As part of the due diligence process, it’s important to regularly review and, if necessary, adjust these provisions. This ensures they remain aligned with the deal's structure and address any potential hidden risks. Taking these steps can help reduce financial uncertainty and make the acquisition process smoother and more secure.

Related posts

• Top 5 Due Diligence Tools for M&A Professionals
• Asset Purchase vs Stock Purchase: Pros and Cons
• Liabilities in Acquisitions: Q&A for Buyers
• Environmental Due Diligence Checklist for SMB Buyers